Advertisement

Sex with minor wife is rape,

rules Supreme Court

New Delhi, October 11- The Supreme Court on Wednesday ruled that sexual intercourse with a minor wife would amount to rape.
A Bench of Justice Madan Lokur and Justice Deepak Gupta read down exception under Section 375 of the IPC that defines rape.
The Bench said the age of consent (which is 18 years) can’t be lowered.
A minor wife would have to file rape complaint within a year of the alleged crime, the top court said.
The ruling harmonises the definition of rape under the IPC with POCSO which treats sex with a minor as crime irrespective of her consent.
Ironically, child marriage is prohibited in India but such marriages, if solemnised, are not void. Child marriage is voidable at the instance of the minor who can exercise the option of repudiating it.
The court had already clarified that it was not dealing with marital rape in general, which women’s rights activists have been demanding to be declared a crime.
The order came on a PIL filed by Independent Thought, an NGO, in 2013, demanding to declare Exception 2 to Section 375 of the IPC unconstitutional. The NGO had contended it violated Articles 14 (right to equality), 15 (right to non-discrimination) and 21 (right to live with human dignity) of the Constitution.
The exception permitted intrusive sexual intercourse with a girl child aged between 15 and 18 only on the grounds that she has been married, the petitioner pointed out and requested the court to declare that the age of consent for sexual relationship should be treated as 18, irrespective of the marital status of the girl child.
The petitioners contended that since the legal age for giving consent for sex is 18, sex with a girl between the age of 15 and 18 in the case of child marriages even with her consent would amount to rape.
Citing the Constitution Bench verdict declaring triple talaq unconstitutional on the grounds of arbitrariness, petitioner's counsel Gaurav Agrawal had argued that Exception 2 to Section 375 of the IPC was arbitrary and, hence should be declared unconstitutional. “It’s arbitrary because all the other laws except Section 375 treat girls below 18 as a child,” Agrawal had submitted.
Citing various reports, the petitioner had said that sexual intercourse with minor girls could lead to physical and mental health hazards.
Maintaining that the general age of consent was 18, the petitioner pointed out that the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006, made it an offence to solemnise the marriage of a girl below 18, though the marriage itself was voidable at the instance of the child and not void.
There was a  disparity in the age of consent under the law, that is, the age of consent is 18 years for a girl who is not married, while the age of consent is 15 years for a girl who is married, the petitioner had pointed out.
The law should not encourage sexual relationship with a girl child less than 18 years under any circumstance and simply because the girl is married, she cannot be subjected to such a violation, the NGO had contended.
Women’s rights activists have been demanding that marital rape in general to be made a criminal offence on the grounds that it forces women to suffer the worst form of sexual violence silently within their matrimonial homes.
But in February 2015, the top court had refused to entertain an MNC executive’s plea to declare marital rape a criminal offence, saying it wasn’t possible to order a change in the law for one person. It was for the legislature to take a call on it, the top court had said.

 

 

English News 

ਖੇਡ ਖ਼ਬਰਾ : 

ਪੰਜਾਬ ਖ਼ਬਰਾਂ : 

ਨਵੇਂ ਲੇਖ : 

Punjab News(ਪੰਜਾਬ ਖ਼ਬਰਾਂ):: 

Khaira fears EVMs will be manipulated
16/12/2017
article thumbnail

Khaira fears EVMs will be manipulated

Jalandhar, December 16- Sukhpal Singh Khaira, AAP MLA and Leader of the Opposition in the Assembly, today expressed fears over the manipulation of EVMs in the MC elections.
Addressing a rally till 5 pm today in the Garha locality here, Khaira violated the code of conduct by overshooting the campaigning deadline of 4 pm.
Khaira said, “There are all [ ... ]


Sec 307 against Akalis stands: Jakhar
11/12/2017
article thumbnail

Sec 307 against Akalis stands: Jakhar
Jalandhar, December 11- State Congress president Sunil Jakhar today said the cases registered against SAD leaders under Section 307 (attempt to murder)of the IPC and for holding dharna and disrupting traffic on the national highway still stand and won’t be withdrawn.
In response to the former Deputy CM Sukhbir Badal’s dare to the Punjab Govern [ ... ]


Will form force to check Cong ‘repression’: SAD
11/12/2017
article thumbnail

Will form force to check Cong ‘repression’: SAD
Chandigarh, December 11- Shiromani Akali Dal president Sukhbir Singh Badal today declared that his party “fully accepts the challenge of a repressive Congress government on the denial of democratic rights for raising our voice in favour of the beleaguered Punjabis who are feeling cheated by it”.
Talking to mediapersons a [ ... ]


MLA: Unaware of pic at police station
07/12/2017
article thumbnail

MLA: Unaware of pic at police station
sangrur, December 7- AICC spokesman and Sangrur Congress MLA Vijay Inder Singla, whose portrait installation with that of CM Capt Amarinder Singh in Sangrur police stations has triggered a controversy, said neither had anyone sought his consent nor had any youth leader spoken to him over the issue before placing his pictures in police stations. Fuming at hi [ ... ]


Ex-MLA attacked in Ferozepur
07/12/2017
article thumbnail

Ex-MLA attacked in Ferozepur   Ferozepur, December 7 - High drama was witnessed at Mallanwala block in the district today when hundreds of Congress workers allegedly attacked senior SAD leaders, including Avtar Singh Minna, SAD district president (rural), Vardev Singh Noni Mann, halqa incharge (Guruharsahai) and former MLA Joginder Singh Jindu. Talking to The Tribune, Minna alleged that th [ ... ]


Rana’s ‘conflict of interest’: HC notice to Punjab
24/10/2017
article thumbnail

Rana’s ‘conflict of interest’: HC notice to Punjab

Chandigarh, October 24- The Punjab and Haryana High Court today put the State of Punjab on notice on a petition filed in public interest for restraining Power and Irrigation Minister Rana Gurjit Singh from dealing with affairs of the Punjab State Power Corporation Limited (PSPCL).
A Bench of Justices Ajay Kumar Mittal and A [ ... ]


Raje govt refers controversial bill to select committee
24/10/2017
article thumbnail

Raje govt refers controversial bill to select committee

Jaipur, October 24- Amid protest by the Opposition and BSP in the Rajasthan Assembly, the Raje government on Tuesday sent the controversial ‘gag’ bill on amendment of the CrPC which it had tabled in the House on Monday to a select committee for review and reference till the next session of the House.
As the House resumed on  [ ... ]


DNA test order for kin of 39 missing in Iraq
22/10/2017
article thumbnail

DNA test order for kin of 39 missing in Iraq

Jalandhar, October 22- Even as the Indian government has failed to get any conclusive clue on the fate of the 39 men missing in Iraq for three years, their families were today asked to undergo DNA tests, raising concerns.
The families, who said they had got messages through police stations and numberdars, were in a quandary over why the need was [ ... ]


Militant killed in encounter in Kupwara district of J&K
22/10/2017
article thumbnail

Militant killed in encounter in Kupwara district of J&K

Srinagar, October 22- A militant was killed in an early morning gunfight in north Kashmir’s Kupwara on Sunday, Army said.
The militant was killed in a gunfight at Langate Handwara, some 70 km from here, during an anti-militancy operation.
“A contact was established at five this morning. A terrorist was killed and a weap [ ... ]


Ahead of May auction, Rana called up Mining Director
07/10/2017
article thumbnail

Ahead of May auction, Rana called up Mining Director

Chandigarh, October 7- Ahead of the sand mining auctions in May, Irrigation and Power Minister Rana Gurjit Singh had called up Director (Mining) Amit Dhaka and enquired about the procedure.
Dhaka has said this in his statement before the Justice JS Narang (retd) Commission.
The commission was formed following The Tribune report on May 25, [ ... ]


 

Random Video 

Latest Added Magzine 

Advertisement

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement